Drew and Charlotte are going away on a rafting trip, leaving Angelica with Stu and Didi. Since no one wants to do anything with her, she pretends to break her leg to get attention.
Angelica is dropped off at Didi and Stu's while Charlotte (accompanied by Drew) go off on a rafting trip for CEOs. Angelica quickly realizes that Didi, Stu, and Grandpa Lou all have things to do and thus don't give her nearly the attention she feels she deserves. So Angelica pretends to fall down the stairs so they'll give her more attention.
Despite Angelica's horrible acting abilities, Didi and Stu rush her to the emergency room. Although she should have been found fine, Angelica's young doctor, Hoagie Doozer, can't keep track of her surname and mixes up her X-ray with that of somebody with the surname Peaches. Because the other person does have a broken leg, Dr. Doozer believes Angelica's leg is truly broken.
That evening at the Pickles' residence, Angelica is made comfortable in bed with her new cast. Stu has kindly set up a buzzer for Angelica to press whenever she wants something, and then is left alone with Tommy. When Tommy asks her about the buzzer, she demonstrates by pressing the button and telling Aunt Didi she's tired of Tommy's company.
As the days pass Angelica eagerly abuses the buzzer and her supposed condition (as well as the potential guilt of the grownups) to have Didi and Stu wait on her hand and foot. Angelica demands to watch TV (even though the only TV in the house is in the downstairs living room), and even uses the buzzer when she wants a tissue just out of reach.
Late one night, Angelica wakes Stu up to demand chocolate pudding, even though there's none in the house. Stu drives to the nearest open convienence store only to find they're out of ready made packets of pudding. But they do have pudding mix. Stu comes home and makes chocolate pudding at 4:00 AM, with Didi walking into the kitchen at one point. Stu takes a bowl of freshly made chocolate pudding up to Angelica, who refuses it because she doesn't want pudding anymore. Stu finally snaps and screams in frustration.
Later that day presumably Didi answers a phone call from the hospital. It's Dr. Doozer, explaining that he mixed up Angelica's X-ray with somebody elses, and that her leg is fine and the cast can be removed immediately. He hangs up the phone and apologizes to Mr. Peaches, a football player who injured his broken leg even more when playing in a game.
Didi gives Stu the happy news, who breaks down in tears of joy. Moments later the doorbell rings and Didi answers it: it's Drew. Didi is surprised to see Drew back several days early. Drew explains that Charlotte had a rafting collision with a kayak and her leg is broken.
Back home at the other Pickles' residence, Charlotte now has a buzzer of her own as she's bedridden, and doesn't hesitate to abuse it not unlike her daughter. Angelica is miserable as Drew hands her food for Charlotte's lunch. Drew tells her that's tough because until Charlotte gets better, they're going to make her as comfortable as possible. Drew turns his attention back to the fridge and asks Angelica about chocolate pudding while the buzzer buzzes urgently. Angelica stands there frozen and nervous as the camera zooms into her eye and ends the episode.
- The part where Stu is making chocolate pudding at four o'clock in the morning became a popular meme and has appeared in many YouTube videos.
- The doctor's name: "Hoagie Doozer" is a parody of Doogie Howser.
- Dr. Hoagie Doozer is a well known doctor in the Rugrats world, because in the episode Rhinoceritis! Angelica uses an official Hoagie Doozer doctor play kit.
- When Dr. Doozer says "Angelica has sustained a massive fracture of the left fibula", Angelica exclaims "Oww!" but holds her right leg because she's unable to keep her own story straight.